Divided Identity

The Middle

I spent most of my time growing up being conflicted. It seemed as if I was always fighting between two opposing halves of myself. One half loved reading books and watching science-fiction movies; the other enjoyed listening to 90s rap with her mom and trying to figure out what the hell Missy Elliot was saying in Work It (it was not, in fact, gibberish). It was only until I was halfway through high school that I realized I didn’t have to choose.

Credit: giphy.com

I could be whoever I wanted to be. I could be the nerd who had a Harry Potter poster on her wall but still knew all the words to her favorite rap songs. I could be the person at the Kendrick Lamar concert who felt comfort in knowing that—by the end of the night—she’d be in bed watching the Star Wars reruns on TV. (I want to say that if I could do anything, it would be to apologize to my younger self. She always felt as if she wouldn’t be enough for anyone if she didn’t choose. I’m sorry I let people make us feel that way.) 

I want to thank the film Dope for helping me realize that I could love and nurture the two halves of myself without compromising who I was. 


“It’s not a ‘hood film or romantic comedy or Tyler Perry. It’s like there’s only two or three things black films can be, and it’s none of those.”

—Rick Famuyiwa, Director of Dope

Dope was a refreshing story in a time where it seemed as if there was only a set number of ways the Black experience could be represented. The movie successfully manages to take the world of Black nerd culture and show it through a modern lens. It follows Malcolm, resident nerd and 90s hip-hop connoisseur, and his two friends Jib and Diggy as they navigate their neighborhood that is riddled with gang violence and drug use.

Credit: giphy.com

In modern-day Inglewood, California, Malcolm is “painfully out of place.” He’s the outsider—the kid who tests well above most of his classmates and is in a punk-rock band with his friends yet listens to old rap albums on his cassette player and has a flat-top haircut. However, while at a party, Malcolm has a run in with a local drug dealer named Dom (who is played by A$AP Rocky) who forces him to deliver a bookbag full of drugs for him. 

From then on, the film explores the merging of two identities that, as it turns out, don’t have to be mutually exclusive. As Malcolm struggles with what to do with the bag, he ventures down a path that shows him what life would be like if he conformed to what society would expect of a man growing up in that type of environment. As the film progresses, his journey takes him down a path of drug-dealing and shoot-outs. But, Malcolm doesn’t want a life like this. Instead, Malcolm dreams of attending Harvard University—an aspiration that is laughed at by mostly everyone in the film.  

“When you don’t fit in, you’re forced to see the world from many different angles.”

— Malcom, Dope

Much like Malcolm, I have struggled with the dichotomy between self-expression and Black, societal expectations. My family forced me to choose between these two identities. My family, mainly my cousins, believed that because I wasn’t fully abiding by the Black community’s expectations for a young, Black woman, I wasn’t wholly Black. They thought that because I had white friends and listened to white artists, I lacked the capabilities necessary to be “Black.” They made jokes about me in front of my friends and other family members. They told me I wasn’t Black enough or, better yet, wasn’t Black at all.

There was no reprieve from this, even with my “friends.” I’ve had numerous white people come up to me and tell me that the reason they liked me so much was that I “wasn’t like other Black girls.” I wasn’t “ghetto,” I spoke in grammatically correct sentences, I understood pop-culture references. They said this to me as if it was a compliment—as if I was supposed to be grateful for the way they stripped me of my identity and painted me as someone else. 

Credit: tenor.com

Because of my premature identity crisis, I—as I so often have done before—tried to change who I was for the betterment of others. I tried to keep my interests a secret at home. I tried to laugh more when my cousins asked me why I couldn’t take a joke. When someone would ask me if I had a favorite movie, I would say something stereotypical instead of what it truly was. When people asked me where I wanted to go to college or what I wanted to major in, I shrugged indifferently. I did what was expected of me. I evaporated.  

Credit: giphy.com

But, it was only until I was well into my Sophomore year of high school that I had a shocking realization: why should I have to compromise what I liked to please others? They surely weren’t doing it for me. So, I said “fuck it.” If you’re going to piss people off, you might as well do it by being wholly and authentically yourself. Dope helped me realize that yes, being Black and liking rap music can be mutually exclusive. Do I enjoy rap music? Of course. But not because anyone told me to. Not because it’s expected of me as a Black person. I love it because it’s who I am—it is one of my favorite forms of self-expression. Would I still be Black if I didn’t enjoy rap music? Of course, because the only boundaries I have are the ones I set for myself.

So, I want you to ask yourself: who would you be if no one was watching? Who would you be if you didn’t force yourself to conform to expectations that are meant to define you? Can you envision that person? Good. Now go and be that person. You will never experience a more satisfying feeling. I guarantee it. 

Being Bad Never Looked So Good

The Middle
Credit: tenor.com

If there is one thing I know, it’s that the first requirement to becoming a world-renowned superhero is that you gotta have one damn good backstory. (The more tragic, the better.) What makes such a captivating backstory is—of course—the villains. These people are specifically bred to make the superhero’s life difficult. They scheme and murder and lie in order to present the hero with a series of problems they never foresaw or deemed themselves capable of handling. Can you even imagine Superman without Lex Luthor, Batman without the Joker, or Spider-Man without the Green Goblin? We can’t—because film writers managed to craft these three-dimensional villains who, at the heart of it, just want to be loved. In the worst possible ways.


Every villain tests the moral capacities of their counterparts. They blur the lines for the superheroes between what is right and wrong, testing their intrinsic values. They are guiltless, wicked, and all-around vicious characters. And we love to hate them. Because…a hero is only as good as their villain. 

Hollywood has provided us with plenty of great villains, each more nefarious and morally compromised than the last. However, what it’s mainly lacked, is three-dimensional villains who are, well…Black. I know, I know—I’ve repeatedly mentioned how films paint Black characters into these villainous roles that render them victims to poor stereotyping and typecasting.

Credit: giphy.com

But, some movies manage to do it really, really well. In a way that has nothing to do with race. Or stereotyping. Or if race dictates a large, important part of who the villain is, they aren’t portrayed in the typical way that most Black bad guys are described on screen. They’re three-dimensional, with goals and painful backstories that led them to where they are today. They’re just as memorable as white villains, if not more so. 

I personally have a top-three favorites list of villains who have been particular pains-in-the-asses for their designated hero. When I first saw them on the big screen, I knew that I wouldn’t be able to forget them anytime soon.


*Spoilers, I guess?*

Credit: giphy.com

My first is our favorite intergalactic villain. I never really got into the Star Wars series until I was well into high school (my senior year), but when I did, I was hooked. Despite the fact that the movies’ chronological history was a bit confusing (seriously, was I supposed to watch the original trilogy first or the prequels? There have been small wars started over this debate) and that they were all over two hours long, these timeless films have resonated with millions of people all over the world. For good reason, too. The painful backstory of our resident bad boy, Anakin Skywalker, still brings a tear to my eye when I think about how he was led astray. It’s true, he did a lot of bad things—but he believed that they were for the right reasons. Isn’t this the logic behind most villains’ choices?

Credit: thestarwarstrilogy.com

Darth Vader is included in my personal list of Black villains because he was actually voiced by James Earl Jones, a Black actor (so he technically still counts). He didn’t get a lot of credit or prestige for this role (we mainly recognize him from The Lion King as Mufasa), but the character itself is one of the most unforgettable roles in film.

Credit: comicbook.com

Darth Vader was such an exceptional villain because he was very familiar with the duality of once being a hero and now being the bad guy. He was the protagonist in his own story and the antagonist in another’s. He battled with light and dark, good and evil, and deciding between what he was supposed to do and making his own choices. His greatest foes were literally his son (gasp) and his former Jedi master. He did terrible things under the guise of Darth Vader, such as dismemberment, torture, and mass murder. Did he feel bad about what he had done? Hmm…debatable, because in his mind he was doing all of these things for one all-encompassing emotion—love. How many bad guys can say that? 


I’m pretty sure you should’ve seen this coming. I don’t think I can write a blog about debunking Black stereotypes without talking about a film that basically raised the middle finger to all of them. Michael B. Jordan’s Erik Killmonger in Black Panther introduced an entirely new villain to modern-day cinema. I particularly like Killmonger’s character because he knew that he had to become a “necessary evil” in order to shape the world in the way he deemed fit. A world where Blacks weren’t being pushed down, where innocents weren’t suffering at the hands of their oppressors daily.

Credit: giphy.com

He’s a character in which we all can empathize with. He was stripped of his childhood early on by the people his father trusted the most—his own family. Killmonger had to lie and plot and kill with the best of them because he honestly believed he was doing what was necessary to make things better for his people. Sure, he probably didn’t go about it in the best way, but I never said he wasn’t flawed.  


Credit: gifer.com

Last but certainly not least is the one-and-only Krall/Balthazar Edison from Star Trek Beyond, played by Idris Elba. Krall’s backstory is albeit a painful one: Edison was a human-turned-alien who once fought for the Federation Starfleet. His resentment towards the Federation soon blossomed into animosity and hatred when they began breaking bread with their enemies.

While on a mission, he and his crewmates are trapped on a distant planet with dwindling resources. After calling for help and receiving no reply, Edison finds a device that allows him to prolong his own life—but he has to “drain” others in order to do it (Source). So, Edison willingly turns himself into the alien “Krall” in order to seek revenge on the government who left him and his crew to die. 

Credit: memory-alpha.fandom.com

What makes Krall such a reputable villain is how particularly human he was. His motivation (in his mind, at least) was pure—he was fighting to prove that alliances ultimately made people weak. Driven by the loss of his crew and the reality of his own unfortunate fate, he turns himself into what he thought the galaxy needed most: a monster. And he makes such a good one. 


What I particularly love about all of these villains is that (for two out of three) their Blackness doesn’t define them. Krall would’ve been the same villain if he was a white guy. He would’ve had the same motivations, the same painful backstory that turned a revered hero into a monster. Darth Vader would have still had the same breathy, dark timbre of voice we all love so much.  In Killmonger’s case his Blackness did define him. But he wasn’t portrayed in this ugly light. The writer’s characterized him in such a way that wouldn’t let the audience hate him. Instead, we sympathized with him. 

“What we don’t need are more one dimensional depictions that rely on stereotypes or black villains with black culture cropped out.” 

Shabazz Malikali

I don’t mind seeing Black people painted as bad guys. It becomes a problem, however, when they are painted in such a negative light that they’re not even human anymore. They’re the stereotypical thugs and criminals that we have been watching on the screen for years. And we don’t like those guys; we can’t relate to them. So, Hollywood, give me more Black villains I can relate to. More three-dimensional, flawed, immoral characters who not only make me love-to-hate-them, but make me understand them as well.

Your Neighborhood Friendly Token Black Girl

The Middle

Like most people my age, I gained a seriously concerning amount of knowledge from watching movies. I learned how to stay true to myself and my friends (Mean Girls), I learned how to dance (Step Up), I learned how to potentially-maybe-one day save the galaxy (Thank you, Star Wars franchise), and I learned that having great power sure as hell does come with a lot of responsibility (Tobey Maguire from Spider-Man, please let me know how you did it). What I didn’t learn, was how to be the best…well, me

Credit: giphy.com

Think back to every, single movie I just mentioned. What do they all have in common? Well, if you said that hardly any of them feature Black characters in main roles you, my friend, are seriously killing it right now. Hardly any of the movies I grew up on placed Black characters in roles where they didn’t exist to be a foil to their white counterpart or where they weren’t playing thugs or criminals. It was hard to connect with characters I saw on the big screen, but seeing as they were all I really had to “look up to,” I didn’t necessarily have a choice. 


When I did happen to connect to a Black, female character on screen, she was nearly always in a secondary role. This meant that I had a very limited number of Black heroes that I could name in my repertoire. Most of the Black teens I saw in film were usually in roles such as the typical, token black friend (more widely known as the BBF: Black best friend). 

Here are a few signs that will help you become a more informed viewer and reveal if you are witnessing the tragic, old-as-time trope that is the BBF: 

Credit: giphy.com
  • Does the character have a role that would exist without the presence of the white character? Do they serve to only advance their story?
  • Are they only there to prove that the white character is very “inclusive” (read: not racist)?
  • Do they have their own story? Do they have a home, a family, or even a pet goldfish named Sir Swims-A-Lot? Or do they just appear whenever their friend needs them in order to be available to their every whim?

If you can answer “yes” to any of these questions, you are sadly experiencing the tired stereotype that is being the token minority. Hey, most of us have probably been there at one point or another or will presumably be that friend in the future. I know I’ve been that friend for most of high school. It was really exhausting and kind of painful. Like, imagine the feeling you get when your sock slips down into your shoe and you aren’t given the chance to fix it.

Credit: giphy.com

Got it? Good. Now take that feeling and multiply it by 100. This isn’t necessarily to say that every token minority in films is portrayed poorly. Some movies successfully manage to take the trope and flip it on its head. For instance, the character of Dionne Davenport from Clueless. 


Credit: pintrest.com

Dionne, also known as Dee, was fierce in her Blackness and unapologetic. Sure, she had a best friend who had no shortage of issues (seriously, the entire premise of the movie is kind of weird) and she might have been lacking a little in the morality department. But, what was so great about her was she didn’t have to sacrifice parts of herself in order to be a good friend. Also, all of her outfits were literally the best (fun fact: I was Dionne for Halloween one year. I did not look half as good). 

Cher: Would you call me selfish?

Dionne: No. Not to your face.

Her character had her own story, her own relationships outside of her friendship with Cher (the main character). When Cher was acting a fool, Dionne set her straight. Sure, she probably wasn’t—and still isn’t—the best role model, but there are certain aspects of her character I can praise her for and her forceful presence is definitely one.


All that being said, the token black friend (or BBF) is a stereotype that has mostly been weeded out due to minorities seeking roles of higher acclaim. However, this doesn’t mean this trope still doesn’t affect me. Even now I can find myself evaluating my closest friendships and trying to ask myself if I’m the token minority.

Do I have my own identity? Do I have my own story? I think that self-discovery—like most things—takes a whole lotta time. It is a never-ending road with more potholes than a New Jersey highway, but I’m glad I’ve got a few good movies to keep me company.